No signings on Deadline Day, but plenty to be positive about
So Transfer Deadline Day came and went and we found ourselves with no incomings, and just the confirmations that both Fabio Vieira and Gabriel Jesus had left the club for Hamburg and Barcelona, respectively. Of course, there’s no news on Martinelli yet, but that’s because the Saudi Pro League deadline day doesn’t finish until 6th September, so there is still time for that to be confirmed.
Ethan Nwaneri has gone on loan, which I think most Arsenal fans are happy with, because we want him to come back having done (hopefully) a season at Dortmund and played plenty of football. If he has a good season in Yelow and Black then maybe he can come and challenge for an important squad place. I also think that, if Madueke hasn’t kicked on, we should be looking at him again as a wide forward.
So let’s break this down into the individual deals – including Martinelli – then finish off with fan reaction and where I’m at today, right?
Fabio Vieira
Probably the easiest and quickest one to get through. He had been on loan to them last season; he’d been on loan at Porto for the season before. He never felt right for our league and always struggled to really make an impact. I remember when he made what I think was his first start for us against Brentford, because Martin Odegaard was missing, and I thought that he might well go on to be a superstar at the club. But it never really happened, and I don’t think that is down to his size. A lot of people talked about how he wasn’t physical; he was too slight, he needed to bulk up, but I never really truly bought in to that. Bernardo Silva isn’t a big bloke, David Silva wasn’t, Tariq Lamptey is small, so there’s plenty of examples of players who can go on in the Premier League despite a smaller and less physical frame. I just think that, ultimately, he never really kicked on and showed the promise he did at Porto and then in the initial time at his career at The Arsenal.
That being said, I do think we’ve been shafted a bit on the fee, which is supposedly £8.6million. TransferMarkt has his value at €18million (£15.43million), he played 31 times, got seven goals and six assists for Hamburg last season, playing nearly 2,500 minutes. He was a regular for Hamburg and they’ve lowballed us there, so the only hope we have to have is that Arsenal got a chunky sell-on fee to ensure that there might be a bit more cash coming our way in the future.
Slight aside – Flo Balogun’s collapsed move to Everton was a bit of a pain in the arse for us, we apparently have a 17.5% sell on clause, which would have netted The Arsenal £7million, so that’ll be a bit of a kicker for the club and the coffers.
Gabriel Jesus
It’s funny how the impact of the details around a transfer can affect your mood on it, because I think most Arsenal fans are happy with the £8.6million we received for Gabriel Jesus from Barcelona. Bearing in mind how much Barca as a club are pretty much arseholes to deal with (think Auba transfer for free a few years back, or Cesc, Petit and Overmars, etc, etc), the fact that they’ve given us ACTUAL MONEY for Gabriel Jesus feels like a bit of a touch from an Arsenal perspective. We know the club were touting the whole “£15 – £20million” at the beginning of the window, but that was never realistic, and I think most Arsenal fans would have been happy with any fee. So in that respect, you have to give some kudos from the club for getting what they got. But it’s not just that, because the rumoured £265,000-per-week wages are also now off the books. If that number is true, then keeping Gabriel Jesus would have cost the club £13.78million for a year. Admittedly, we’re in September, so maybe it would have been close to 44 weeks wages they’d have had to pay, but that’s still £11.66million. So to go from that as a cost to money coming in for that fee is a £20million+ swing for the club. That’s not an insignificant amount. And for a player who has missed 80 games for us since he joined, and found himself a peripheral player this last season gone, you have to be happy with that.
Gabriel Martinelli
Whilst this hasn’t happened yet, I think we all know it probably will, and at £60million I guess that’s decent enough. The hyperinflation of the Premier League and dodgy dealings of some of the clubs in this league has distorted the pricing for players, because before all of this nonsense kicked off with Elliot Anderson, you’d have probably have said £60million for Martinelli is good work. He has served his time, we all still love him, he was a hard worker, but his output in domestic competitions fell through the floor last season and I think that’s why the club have decided to take this deal, despite it clearly leaving us short in attack. Which brings me to the final discussion piece for today…
The transfer window as a whole – for fans and for me
Personally, I’m quite chilled about everything. I think we’re stronger in defence with the arrival of Konsa, I think we’re stronger in midfield with the arrival of Bruno, so it is just that attack that might be problematic. The options on that left wing are the biggest challenge and risk, because in total when you look at the numbers from last season, we have Martinelli and Trossard’s minutes that equated to a combination of 5,306 minutes across all competitions, 19 goals and 18 assists across the two players. That’s what supposedly needs to be found, but I don’t think it needs to be as analogue as that, because whilst Tzolis and Eze will share those minutes, we are all also hoping that Havertz, Saka, Madueke, plus Merino, can all contribute more than they did last season. If you take the attacking group as a whole, and just those players who played in the main attacking positions (so I’ve included Martinelli, Trossard, Saka, Havertz, Jesus, Gyokeres, Merino, Madueke) – you’re looking at 16,347 minutes, 72 goals 40 assists. We have to better that. If you’re moving Eze to that left-wing position, he’s got to better his seven goals and two assists last season. I think he does that, easily, but I also think Saka – if fit – beats his seven goals and five assists, too. I think Havertz – again, if fit – beats his seven goals and five assists. I think Tzolis should at least be able to match one of Martinelli or Trossard’s outputs, plus we have Merino who – again, if fit -will surely better his four goals and three assists. I haven’t even factored in that Max is a year older…
The point I’m trying to make is that whilst we all know we need to strengthen, whilst I wanted a high-profile left-winger to come in, I am not minded to spend cash on players just to make up numbers – Fofana, as an example, probably would have been that guy.
We have a talented squad that can cope with the new season. They just need to stay fit. I’m hopeful many of them will.
Catch you all tomorrow.
Quick PS – we did the Same Old Arsenal pod last night, which you can re-watch on YouTube (or wherever you get your pods) here if you are so inclined.